Differences of Sunni and Shia Law on Testamentary Succession

In this forum we will post and discuss about the succession law in Pakistan. the succession law of all religion. letter of administration, will and probate matter and related laws and issues.

Differences of Sunni and Shia Law on Testamentary Succession

Unread postby Admin » Fri Dec 06, 2013 4:39 am

(1) Capacity to make will
Hanfi Law – Puberty and same
Shia law – 10 (age of discernment)

(2) Consent of heirs to distribution of an otherwise ultra vires will:
Hanfia Law –consent after the death of the testator
Shia Law- consent can be given either after the testator’s death or duing his lifetime.

(3) Abatement:
Hanfi Law – proportionate reduction
Shia Law – first in time prevails.

(4) Bequests to an heir:
Hanfi Law – bequests to an heir are ultra vires
Shia Law- a bequest can be made in favor of an heir within one third of the distribution.

(5) Legatee Predeceases testator:
Hanafi law –legacy lapses
Shia Law –the heirs of the legatee have the option of accepting or rejecting the legacy

(6) Homicide:
Hanafi Law – if the legatee caused the death of the legato in a direct manner whether intentional otherwise the bequest is ultra vires.
Shia Law- only intentional homicide will deprive the legatee of the bequest, although in this case the bequest is batil and the legatee is absolutely barred.
Iqbal International Law Services®
Phone: 0333-2171556
Site Admin
Posts: 463
Joined: Tue May 22, 2012 7:28 pm
Location: Karachi, Pakistan

Return to Succession Law

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 0 guests